On its own, I found Rogue One to be very enjoyable and superbly made. There’s every good praise to be made for its story line, effects and artistic direction.
The basic problem about it – and I think that this is what might generate some reservations among fans – is that the story has very little to do with the essential, central Star Wars story line, which we have come to know as being the downfall and redemption of Anakin Skywalker. Of course, the film absolves itself of this fault by including the phrase A Star Wars Story in its title. This subtitle doesn’t appear on screen, but is part of the film’s official title. So, I think one needs to take the subtitle literally and make an effort to get over the fact that this is not a Skywalker story.
Beware of spoilers from this point onwards, if you have not yet seen Rogue One.
Despite what I said above, Rogue One does center again on a family broken apart by the evil Empire’s plans, much like what happens in the seven episodes of Star Wars. This time round, however, the reason for the breakup is less spiritual, less esoteric than the corresponding events in the Skywalker timeline.
Thumbs Up and Novelties
Well, at last, we see the true scale of an Imperial Cruiser as it hovers above the city of Jedha. I had been wanting to see something like that. (The same goes for TIE fighters and The Force Awakens was the first Star Wars film where we see TIE fighters next to their human pilots.)
The spectacular aerial battle in the rain on Eadu rivals the battle over the lake in The Force Awakens. However, the latter is still my favourite.
The other spectacular battle over Scarif harks back to the one over Endor in Return of the Jedi and I was very happy to hear the various squadron leaders reporting in just before it ensued, this particular detail being reminiscent of the future attack on the Death Star in A New Hope (only a film away!). Oh, and I did enjoy that scene with the Hammerhead Corvette causing those two Star Destroyers to crash!
The ground battle on Scarif was, of course, very impressive and kudos for the beautiful scene of Chirrut’s slow advance forward towards the communications master switch before being shot. It was saddening to watch the heroes falling one by one.
The final scene, when Tarkin orders the destruction of the base, shows the full ruthlessness of the Empire and its indifference even to the lives of its own officers. This is perfectly embodied by Tarkin himself.
And the film leads very nicely to the point where the events of A New Hope will begin, with Tantive IV leaving the scene of the battle and carrying the plans of the Death Star.
How ironic that Galen Erso used the same pet name for the Death Star project and his little girl, knowing that Jyn would thus be able to identify the stored plans when she came across that very name. The irony is carried even further when you realise that the Death Star’s primary function is to destroy planets and reduce them to… stardust.
There is also another interesting irony: The Jedi use the Kaiburr crystals for their lightsabers while the Empire uses them to destroy planets.
Interestingly enough, Rogue One is the first Star Wars film where the names of planets are given on screen. I noticed, however, that no such names were given for Jyn Erso’s home planet and the one where Orson Krennic visited Darth Vader.
Nods and Cameos
I first saw the name Kaiburr ages ago in Alan Dean Foster’s novel Splinter of the Mind’s Eye.
Chirrut and Baze are described as being “Guardians of the Whills”. I believe the name “Whills” comes from the very first novelisation of Star Wars by George Lucas himself, back in 1977. The prologue to that briefly describes the downfall of the Old Republic and the seizing of power by the “ambitious Senator Palpatine”. Underneath the prologue is the phrase:
From the First Saga
Journal of the Whills
I noticed Dr. Evazan running into Jyn and Cassian in the streets of Jedha. And, then, there was the proverbial chess game being played outside the cell where Cassian, Chirrut, Baze and Bodhi were being held, as well as a Twi’lek dancing.
I smiled when I heard K-2SO nearly phrasing “I’ve got a bad feeling about this”!
Oh dear! Darth Vader was probably shown at his meanest ever when he butchered all those poor Rebels in one of the last scenes.
Prior to seeing the film, I had predicted that we would see Vader force-choking Krennic to death, but then I thought that that would have been due to Krennic’s inability to stop the Rebels from stealing the Death Star plans. Well, I only got it half-right, since the choking was for another reason and not fatal.
Krennic eventually met his bitter end, brought about by the very machine that he was so proud of…
I noticed Vader’s voice to be somewhat aged in relation to the one in Episodes 4-6, but there’s no escaping reality: It has been 11 years since Revenge of the Sith was released.
Grand Moff Tarkin
Well, that was a surprise. They did a really good job creating a digital image of Moff Tarkin to superimpose on the real actor who portrayed him. You could tell it wasn’t really Peter Cushing, but the resemblance was really very good and I must admit that – while watching the film – I kept wondering “Is it CG?”, “Is it CG?”.
I was even more surprised to see her! I was sure there wasn’t any chance of seeing the Princess, just the departure of Tantive IV from the battle scene. I am glad to have been proved wrong. You could tell that she was CG, but it didn’t matter.
I could not help noticing that some scenes, which I had got used to seeing in the trailers, didn’t make it to the final cut. Most notable of these was the one where a TIE fighter confronts Jyn Erso on that platform where she had gone to transmit the plans up to the Rebel fleet. I was waiting to see that TIE fighter, but it never appeared. What happened?
And then, I never remember seeing Mon Mothma talking about the Empire’s upcoming “weapons test”, or Orson Krennic saying “the power we are dealing with here is immeasurable”.
I am not sure, but did they also miss out a scene with Cassian and Jyn running on the ground on Scarif with Jyn holding the disk with the Death Star plans?
Rogue One is a Star Wars story indeed, well worth seeing. Here’s to many more!